Community Corner

Top Island Restaurants: Do You Agree with the Lists?

Where are the best restaurants on Martha's Vineyard? We bring you the Island's top eateries according to Yelp, TripAdvisor, Boston magazine and President Barack Obama.

By Louisa Hufstader

Yelp's highest-rated Martha's Vineyard restaurants
:

  1. State Road, West Tisbury
  2. The Red Cat Kitchen at Ken'n'Beck, Oak Bluffs
  3. Sidecar Café and Bar, Oak Bluffs
  4. 7A Foods, West Tisbury
  5. Lambert’s Cove Inn & Restaurant, Vineyard Haven
  6. Détente, Edgartown
  7. Dinghy Dogs, Oak Bluffs (closed)
  8. Offshore Ale Company, Oak Bluffs
  9. Slice of Life, Oak Bluffs
  10. The Black Dog Tavern, Vineyard Haven
  11. Nancy's Snack Bar, Oak Bluffs
  12. Little House Café, Vineyard Haven
  13. Artcliff Diner, Vineyard Haven
  14. Faith's Seafood Shack, Aquinnah
  15. Biscuits, Oak Bluffs
  16. The Net Result, Vineyard Haven
  17. Tisberry Frozen Yogurt & Smoothies, Vineyard Haven
  18. Oyster Bar Grill (closed), Oak Bluffs
  19. Skinny's Fat Sandwiches, Oak Bluffs/Edgartown
  20. Scottish Bakehouse, Vineyard Haven
TripAdvisor's highest-rated Martha's Vineyard restaurants:
  1. Back Door Donuts, Oak Bluffs
  2. Larsen's Fish Market, Menemsha
  3. Menemsha Fish Market, Menemsha
  4. The Scoop Shack, Edgartown
  5. The Terrace at the Charlotte Inn, Edgartown
  6. Black Sheep and Trio, Edgartown
  7. Slice of Life, Oak Bluffs
  8. The Red Cat Kitchen at Ken'n'Beck, Oak Bluffs
  9. Martha's Vineyard Chowder Company, Oak Bluffs
  10. Blue Canoe Waterfront Grille, Vineyard Haven
  11. Waterside Market, Vineyard Haven
  12. Lambert’s Cove Inn & Restaurant, Vineyard Haven
  13. Dock Street Coffee Shop, Edgartown
  14. Lucky Hank’s, Edgartown
  15. Détente, Edgartown
  16. Artcliff Diner, Vineyard Haven
  17. The Net Result, Vineyard Haven
  18. Tisberry Frozen Yogurt & Smoothies, Vineyard Haven
  19. Offshore Ale Company, Oak Bluffs
  20. Atria, Edgartown
Boston magazine's annual "Best of ... Cape Cod & the Islands" list:
Where President Barack Obama dined on his 2013 vacation here:
What do you think of these lists? Do you have any restaurants to add? Tell us in the comments.

[Editor's note: If you think you're seeing double on this article, it's because we ran it back in August. We wanted it in our new "Weekender" section, so we've copied it over.]


Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here

More from Martha's Vineyard