First, in all fairness, we need to ask ourselves: Do we behave this badly when we ourselves are travelers in faraway places? To answer honestly, we must sit alone in a dark room and go deep within. Finished? OK, I’ve just done my own agonizing reappraisal, and I’ve come up with this response, which I hope matches your own:
No. We are, we Vineyarders, by and large smarter than the small minority of exhaustively stupid tourists who arrive on our shores in the summer. How do we know this?
Well, if we were this clueless, how could we ever manage to put up rosehip jam in the fall, and look after our neighbors’ pipes and call 911 if we see icicles, and cope with the ferry schedule, and keep body and soul together in the poorest, drunkest principality of Massachusetts? Satisfied that we’re basically geniuses? OK, let’s get cracking:
With the help of some of my Facebook friends, I’ve come up with categories of, to use the Latin, stupiditus turistus, ending with a Vineyard doozy of a tourist encounter so dazzlingly dumb it has entered the realm of urban legend (and which I’ve tracked down to its original eyewitness).
Let’s start, however, with the most famous enduring idiocy of all: The Chappaquiddick Question, as in Where is The Dike Bridge or, as one local wag calls it, The Kennedy Car Wash (I know; ouch):
Taxi cab owner, Adam Wilson, once had a passenger comment, “I want to go to Chappaquiddick – you know, to the place where he killed her.”
I do believe interest in this site has waned. It’s even possible the younger generation, apart from those raised on MV, have never heard about that fateful night back in July of 1969, when young Ted Kennedy, with a young lady named Mary Jo -- well, you know the rest. (I’m addressing an extremely smart and knowledgeable crowd here.)
In any event, down through the years, scores of tourists have asked to be pointed to the location of this fiasco. First of all, they need to be apprised that they must journey to a second, smaller island, to whit Chappaquiddick which, eyed from Edgartown, has often been mistaken for Nantucket, which leads to another stoopid turist issue which is:
Some of these people have no idea where they are:
Nancy Rogers confided, “My dad used to work on the boat and people would drive off and ask how to get to Martha’s Vineyard.”
Alana Pagnotti said, “A lady pulled up to me on Main Street in Vineyard Haven and asked me how to get to Hyannisport.”
It’s not atypical, by the way, for vacationers to be totally flummoxed about where they happen to be and what they’re seeing.
Holly Alaimo reflected that during her days as a concierge at a Boston hotel, any number of guests asked for directions to the Statue of Liberty.
Did she suggest, “Rent a car, get on I-95 and drive for five-and-half hours”? No, but she was tempted.
The rascally Warren Gosson, when he spies people pouring over a map, likes to observe, “You cannot get there from here.” After that, he provides authentic directions.
This begs the question of people not quite getting what it means to be positioned on an island. Some people seem to think we’re adrift in the Atlantic, as if our soil sits atop an extremely large floatation device.
Karen Coffey wrote, “I once had a tourist with a thick New Jersey accent ask ‘Is this island surrounded on all four sides by water?’ I thought it was a trick question.”
Carole Flanders wrote, “My mother used to ask if the island was going to sink and spent most of the time in the house praying.”
Hey! It’s possible our rock still floats thanks to Carole’s mom’s request for divine intervention!
A random sampling of mindless queries: Ted Box, boat-builder and furniture-maker, wrote, “When I was doing my driftwood furniture, you’d be surprised how many people asked me if I found my pieces that way on the beach. I, of course, informed them of the difficulty of finding them with drawers still in place.”
Rebecca Gilbert of Native Earth Teaching Farm revealed she established her institute because she was tired of explaining the difference between a chicken and a duck while showing her animals at the Ag Fair.
Paulette Hayes has had guests stop to take pictures of cows – apparently they have never seen them in the “wild.”
And Barbara Beichek reminds us of that perennial question: “Can you buy food here?” As if this is the frontier and the Wells Fargo Wagon has come and done gone.
Two other big areas of cerebral challenge:
1). People who remark upon Oaks Bluff, to which Susan Dawson contributed the following episode: “I have a T-shirt that says ‘Oaks Bluff’ and once, walking down Circuit, a woman whacked her husband upside the head and said, ‘See? I told you it was Oaks Bluff!’”
2). Any question pertaining to the Black Dog tends to sound idiotic.
Tim DeFelice was once queried by a woman, “You know that T-shirt with the black dog on it? Where do you get those?”
Tourists on the snuffle for Black Dog gear simply strike us as, well, sub-par on the intelligence scale. When I shared my first bookstore space with the Black Dog General Store in Oak Bluffs, parents often parked their kids in my shop while they trolled for sweatshirts, key-rings, coffee mugs and stuffed black puppies next door. When they returned to collect their brood and the kids held up reading material, the ‘rents would declare, horrified, “We’re not buying you a BOOK!”
And let’s not forget the visitors who mistake us for Plymouth Plantation.
Ms. Beichek wrote about her pet peeve of folks who wander down the middle of Circuit Avenue, “not the sidewalk, because, after all, this is an amusement park, not a town of real people. We’re all getting paid to look like we live here.”
Similarly, Sissy Biggers, whom I recently encountered in Oaks Bluff, told me that one time when she and some guests sat out on her front porch overlooking Ocean Park, a group of Chinese visitors stood and stared at them as if they were on situ to perform.
Sissy said, “I belted out a rendition of 'Me And Bobbie Magee.'”
And finally we come to the urban legend of all stoopid turist trix, and the attribution goes to our beloved Betty Burton: “A woman asked me if she could get in front of me at Cronig’s. 'I’m on vacation,’ she explained.
Betty blurted out, 'Yes, well, I’m on my lunch hour.’”
Betty admits that she had the usual after-burn wish that she'd come up with a wittier riposte.
Any ideas? Please weigh in. You never know when this could happen to you, and you want to be ready. Winner gets a Black Dog T-shirt.
Nina Lisa Maria
6:24 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
I was at Old Sculpin Gallery this Thanksgiving weekend, next to the chappy ferry, and some tourists on bikes asked for directions to the bridge. I haven't been to Chappy in years so had trouble describing exactly how to get there. Understandably the couple were confused, so they asked again, how do they get to the bridge TO Chappaquiddick? I said oh, you have to take the ferry. They asked again, the bridge TO Chappaquiddick, because I just didn't get them apparently. I said you have to take the ferry, then futilely started explaining how the hurricane washed out the over land bridge and that it was really long anyway, you need a 4 wheel drive vehicle and I think a pass, and near impossible for their bikes... I just didn't understand that though it was November, they are still clueless, and I was only confusing them more. My bad. They biked away perplexed without a word, possibly to continue their search for the bridge to Chappy, and did not take the ferry.
Louisa Hufstader
10:44 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
OMG, people are STILL looking for the "Bridge to Chappaquiddick"?! LOL. Back in the 70s we rotten kids frequently used to provide such seekers (we considered them ghouls) with detailed directions ... to the landfill on Clevelandtown Road. "Watch for the seagulls," we'd tell 'em.
I think I permanently wrecked my karma for asking directions anywhere else in the world.
Nina Lisa Maria
6:42 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Another couple asked if Jaws was filmed here. I explained how they wanted to use the gallery, but could not, so they built an exact replica (Jaws questions are common in the gallery). Again I was confused about what they meant and had assumed they had more Vineyard knowledge than they did. So after ignoring my first explanation of the scene shot in the gallery's replica, they patiently asked me which beach was used? I explained how as someone who has now lived on Mv for over 19 years, I was tickled to watch the movie and recognize around 5 different beaches for that one scene where the shark appears to go from state beach and Eastville to Menemsha pond, and people are running around on various other beaches but it's all edited into one amazing scene, and how wreckage of the boat was in Menemsha for so long... They were so perplexed and asked again but where was Jaws filmed? frustrated, finally I said yes, Edgartown is Amity, and pretended I didn't know directions how to get to the beach where Jaws was filmed. I guess business was too slow that day and I talk way too much.
Claire Dillon
6:44 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
This piece sounds like an alcohol induced ramble and should never have been published. This author ought to get of the island more often.
Carolyn O'Daly
10:43 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Who are you and where did your sense of humor go?
Charlie Nadler
12:25 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
You spelled off wrong you should get to the dictionary more often.
Holly Nadler
4:16 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
See, Claire Dillon, you've even incensed my son! No Black Dog T shirt for you, girlfriend!
Barb Nahoumi
7:10 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
To Betty Burton,
I would have replied, "If you are on vacation, you have time to wait."
Michael West
7:21 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Not sure who this Dillon character is, Holly, one of your relatives maybe?
I must be just as addled as you because I thought this was one of your very best blog posts. Had me laughing more than once and smiling all the way through.
Kudos to Betty Burton for her kind but pointed rejoinder.
Holly Nadler
7:44 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Actually, it was a little rough what Claire said, but how did she know I need to get off the island more? My last trip was an overnight to Boston in September! But then I get to take a long break with my homies in California, so that could help.
Holly Nadler
7:55 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
I just re-read what Ms. Dillon said about this column sounding like an "alcohol-induced ramble." It seems pretty dry-eyed to me. 'Course I'm a big hung-over.
Holly Nadler
9:34 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Meant to say a "bit" hung-over. Just goes to prove Ms. Dillon's point.
Jason Peringer
7:57 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
My response: "Well, I'm on work release for the day..." :-P
Nina Lisa Maria
8:07 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
I definitely need to get off the island more. But an alcoholic ramble would have incomplete sentences and wrong punctuation, at the least.
Chip Coblyn
8:13 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
To the line jumper--
Sure you can, as soon as I pay for these groceries.
Holly Nadler
8:15 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Chip, or how about, "Sure you can jump the line, as long as you pay for MY groceries"?
Sissy Biggers
8:37 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Thanks for letting us share! That visit from the Chinese tourists inspired a trophy and a mural at Biggers Cottage. If we didn't love the tourists who inspire parallel parking drinking games on Ocean Park -- how else would we spend those long summer nights!
Holly Nadler
9:36 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Sissy, remember the fourth of July when Peter Norton set up a huge flat-screen TV outside his house and ran video-tape of his place burning down? Guess he was tired of being asked about that.
Walter L. Isaacs
9:13 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Dillon is a knucklehead with little sense of humor. I've been asked too many times," Is there a bridge to the mainland? When told no, they ask either "why not, or when is one going to be built?" Maybe they were from Staten Island?
Holly Nadler
9:27 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Walter, I forgot about the bridge-to-the-mainland question! Clearly this column is going to need a Part Deux!
Carolyn O'Daly
10:45 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Holly...hope your Black Dog comments don't get you called an elitist by Mr. Douglas. Once wrote an essay for MV Magazine about opening day at the Black Dog and he proceeded to remove all his advertising from the Gazette and refused to carry it or the Island Guide at his venues. Apparently there are several people here with no sense of humor!
Jade Blevins
11:11 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
I worked summers on the Island for a few years...my favorite tourist question..."How do you get to the beach" as if there was only one. I always wanted to tell people to pick a road and drive until they hit water.
George hartman
11:17 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
How many of "us" could get around in the New York subway system without asking dumb questions, or even have seen a subway in the "wild"?
Martha Magee
11:23 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
I love the summer people
daytrippers too
always sad to see them go
Love it all, I really do!
Vineyard summer = magic
(a bit much since the Clintons, true)
but island winters make me very blue
I just love the island when its all happening!
Give me a sunny, August day, teeming with tourists!
Oaks Bluff teeshirts, ice cream cones, long lines, and traffic!
I'll take that any day over the raw, grey, dark, frigid, floating desolation!
John Paul
11:46 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
I once had someone ask me, "which way to the water?"
Holly Nadler
11:46 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Zut alors, Carolyn! Did the Gazette give you a hard time for Mr. Douglas Behaving Badly? And, Jade, that is too funny about asking how to get the "the" beach! George, just 'cause we're living here now doesn't mean we haven't dwelled in cities and learned the subway system and, finally, Martha, love your poem; it's good to be reminded of the fun season!
Carolyn O'Daly
2:20 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
No...it seems they had had issues with him before....
John Eide
11:55 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
Oh the endless list of heartwarming memories (that keep getting refreshed!). I submit (intentionally, and appropristly as per Rod Serling): height of season; thronged Circuit Ave; car stops and waits... and waits (someone's verrrry slowwwly pulling out of an upstream parking spot?) - nope - from stages left and right a two pronged horde swarms and packs into the waiting stagecoach like sardines cramming a circus clown's mini. But, wait.... there's more. This overfed coach, now probably riding directly on its axles, slowly rolls onward (as the inhabitants urgently scan left and right) - about 50' further in its painful journey, one sardine starts pointing and waving frantically at a store and, yup, the damned car stops so as to projectile vomit it's contents. This made all the more logistically challenging because now all the "wrong siders" have to scramble across towards the other-sided target. Sorta fun to watch from the sidewalk - from the car behind the amusement park shuttle, not so much.
Cynthia Mascott
2:05 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
When I moved to the Island and Charlie and I were in Edgartown and I looked at Chappaquiddick and I thought it was Nantucket and I said "That's no two hour ferry ride" at which point Charlie said he wanted to be let out of the car b/c he could ride with someone as stupid as me. I think he actually did get out of the car for a couple of minutes.
Trina Mascott
3:13 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
Trina Mascott
Here'a report from California's Palm Springs area whose winter tourist season is just beginning: it's all about cars. We seldom see our tourists face to face. So our complaints are about these visitors, mostly from Oregon, Washington and Canada, who drive too slowly in our fast lanes. Our main communication with them isn't verbal but is done via horn blowing. And Michael West, I'm taking your crack about Holly's relatives personally!
Laura
5:02 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
I was working out by myself at an island gym one summer day, when a woman started asking me what it was like to live on the Vineyard year round. After we chatted for a few minutes about the cost of living here, she asked me to tell her where the year-rounders shop. I glanced around to make sure no one could overhear me and told her that there was a secret shopping mall out by the airport. But only year-rounders could shop there. I really had her going and finally had to tell her that we shop at the same places that she did. I couldn't believe she believed me!
Holly Nadler
5:11 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012
Laura, you mean there isn't a secret mall? I've been waiting to be given the specially coded map!
Joyce Wagner
9:04 am on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Anyone who says "Oaks Bluff" should be sent right back to Wood Holes.
Bloodyrue Andrue
4:08 pm on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Many years ago now, I went to pick up a relative at the airport. A couple got off the plane and said something like: "This isn't what I thought Nantucket looked like." I was wondering how the rest of their trip turned out.
Holly Nadler
9:28 am on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Joyce, I've actually lobbied for years to officially change our town's name to Oaks Bluff. Try it: It rolls trippingly off the tongue, whereas Oak Bluffs -- try saying it over the phone and you need to enunciate that impossible "ffs" sound. Then because you know it's incomprehensible, you go through the whole business of spelling "f as in Frank, f as in Frank again, then s as in Sam." Bloody hell!
Holly Nadler
9:31 am on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
I'd like to propose a campaign of writing a return address as Oaks Bluff, because all we really need is the zip code; we could write Pyongyang 02557 and no one, certainly not the postman, would care.
Bloodyrue Andrue
4:11 pm on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
A few years ago, there was actually an SSA schedule with Oaks Bluff printed on it.
Hydra
9:47 pm on Tuesday, December 4, 2012
A tourisst asked the best place to get crabs, and I tolx him it was at the Lamp Post.
Holly Nadler
7:39 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012
Just heard a couple of new ones from Tim Felice: One woman said to him, "We were just on a beach with seaweed. Are there any beaches without seaweed?" And the other: "Is there a beach near the water?" Hmmm . . . this is even worse than I thought!